I love the arXiv blog comments. I kind of want to start a new blog called: arXiv blog (no amateurs). Mostly for the fact that it would actually more likely draw people such as those we see here.
And regardless of whether you think special or general relativity (or quantum mechanics) is a Platonic ideal, or that some other theory of your own devising is, you are limited by the fact that, because of experimental evidence, your theory must reduce in some limit to those theories -- just like how quantum mechanics and general relativity reduce to Newtonian classical mechanics and Newton's gravitational force law and special relativity to Galilean invariance.
Any particle falling through singularity would evaporate first
ReplyDelete